Donor challenge: Your generous donation will be matched 2-to-1 right now. Your $5 becomes $15! Dear Internet Archive Supporter,. I ask only. Is the Hadith below authentic? “What I fear for my followers is a large stomach, excessive sleep, idleness and lack of certainty (in faith).” (Kanz. book Kanzul ummal vol 13 hadees shareefin PDF format.
|Published (Last):||24 November 2016|
|PDF File Size:||10.83 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||3.26 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
Sign up using Facebook. Post as a guest Name. Assuming Damascus to be actually a reference to a broader region it can perhaps be understood to mean Nazareth where both Jesus Umkal and his Mother had to seek shelter on their return from Egypt for the fear of Archelaus. Their mosques will be splendidly furnished but destitute of guidance.
First of them goes as:. The first is the safe count and the second is the more realistic count. Albani called it Daeef in Silsala Daeefa No. Hassan 3 So as a whole book, we can’t call it authentic like we call sahih bukhari or sahih muslim authentic books. There is not even a shred ksnzul evidence for Qadiani stance. The narration is weak and unauthentic. This narration is also weak. The following is the translation of one such narration as it appears on the AlIslam.
And JAMIA is also a type of hadees collection, like sahih is a type of collection, jamia is a type of collection in which author’s main intent is only to collect all the ahadees he can find in one place.
We refer to Biblical evidences only because they go in line with our sources of value and we are allowed to refer to the narrations of People of Book if they go along with Quran and Hadith.
Had this verse something to do with what Qadianis assert Holy Prophet PBUH would surely have told his companions about it but he never said anything on those lines.
Are Hadiths in the Book, Kanz Al Ummal, Authentic?
Not caring much about authenticity or anything. All this has been explained above in the light of classical Islamic narrations and Biblical evidences. Sign up using Email and Password. It’s a collection of 47, hadith by al-Mutaqqi al-Hindi. Given the figures we can speculate that there are at least 8, authentic reports in Kanz but closer to 27, and there are at least 6, weak reports but closer to 31, with a buffer of 26, to 39, wiggle room between them.
I hope someone will add the count in this answer. Same is the umma, here as explained above. Qadianis use a couple of narrations to meet their ends. This clearly gives a notion of being saved from some trouble.
However, it is well known to be full of weak reports as the author and editor Suyuti and Hindi did not intend to collect only Sahih Hadith. Sign up or log in Sign up using Google. Many of it’s hadiths are weak.
Some of the Ahmadiyya leaders try to stereotype contemporary Islamic scholarship as a whole using some narrations recorded in Hadith works. Their divines will be the worst people under the Heaven; strife will issue from them and avert to them.
This narration has nothing in it to to help Qadianis! How many weak ahadiths does it have?
Kanzul Ummal Vol – 13
Sadiq 2 Authenticity of Kanz al-Ummal? Hamid, Ibn Asaakir etc. Jerusalem and finished prayers in Al-Aqsa Mosque she climbed up to Mt.
hadith – Authenticity of Kanz al-Ummal? – Islam Stack Exchange
And i know quite a few zaeef ahadees in this book, but i don’t know the exact count though. In the following lines we understand it in the light of authentic sources and valid reasoning. Some scholars have called the essence of this Hadith as true but surely this Hadith only points to the fact that Jesus PBUH also left his place for the sake of Deen and we just saw how narrations and other evidences agree that he did travel to Egypt and then to a district around Damascus.
Email Required, but never shown. Jami Saghir is included in Kanz. There are two ways of approaching the answer and a buffer. Assuming there is no repetition in the Tafsir, there are 26, reports more than what Al-Albani commented kanzuo and 39, more than Kanz.
Those who have known classical and basic tafasir know how ridiculous this assertion is.